Vermont pets are property in divorce — but states like California, Illinois, New York, Alaska now consider pet's "best interests." Most states still treat pets as property to be awarded to one party.
Published May 9, 2026
## Pet custody in divorce in Vermont
Pets are deeply emotional issues in divorce, but most state laws still classify them as **property** — not children. Vermont courts handle pet custody through a patchwork of property and (in some states) limited "best interests" analysis.
## The fundamental issue — pets are property
**Traditional law:**
- Pets = personal property (chattel)
- Awarded to one party in property division
- No "custody" technically
- No visitation orders typically
- Best interests of pet not considered
**Practical effect:**
- Court considers ownership history
- Who paid for / cared for
- Pre-marital ownership
- Gifted vs purchased
- Who has time / space for pet
## Modern shift — "best interests" states
**States that consider pet's well-being:**
- **Alaska** (first, 2017)
- **Illinois** (2018)
- **California** (2019)
- **New York** (2021)
- **Maine** (2021)
- **New Hampshire** (2022)
- **Rhode Island** (2023)
- **DC** (2024)
- More states adopting
**These states allow:**
- Court consideration of pet's well-being
- Joint pet custody arrangements
- Visitation orders
- Care + custody factors
- Sometimes specific pet-care provisions
## Factors courts consider
**Even in property states, courts weigh:**
- **Pre-marital ownership** — who owned pet before marriage
- **Primary caretaker** — who fed, walked, vet visits
- **Financial responsibility** — who paid food, vet, grooming
- **Emotional bond** — testimony, photos, videos
- **Children** — pet living with kids' primary parent often
- **Living situation** — fenced yard, space, allergies
- **Time availability** — work schedules
- **Future care plans** — work, travel, lifestyle
- **Other pets** — keeping pets together
- **Pet's preferences** (in some courts)
## Common arrangements
**Sole custody to one party:**
- Most common
- Other party may have visitation by agreement
- Property settlement covers pet
**Shared custody:**
- Possible by agreement
- Sometimes ordered in best-interest states
- Rotation schedule (week-on, week-off)
- Holidays / vacations
- Often parallels child custody
**Visitation only:**
- One party owns
- Other has visitation rights
- Specific schedule
- Less common formal arrangements
## Negotiating pet custody
**During divorce:**
- Discuss informally first
- Mediation helpful
- Consider pet's needs
- Be realistic about lifestyle
- Don't use pet as leverage for other issues
**Settlement provisions:**
- Sole vs shared custody
- Cost-sharing (vet, food, grooming)
- Decision-making (vet care, training)
- End-of-life decisions
- Travel / boarding arrangements
- Pet death / new pets
- Termination of arrangement
## Multiple pets
**Common to split pets:**
- Each spouse takes some
- Bonded pets stay together
- Children's pets sometimes follow children
- Special-needs pets considerations
## Service / emotional support animals
**Special considerations:**
- ADA documentation
- Disability needs
- Often automatically with disabled spouse
- Documentation of dependency
## Costs of pet litigation
**Pet custody can be expensive:**
- Mediation: $500-$2,500
- Litigation: $5,000-$25,000+
- Often disproportionate to pet's monetary value
- Emotional cost significant
**Often best to settle.**
## Special situations
**Pet purchased during marriage as gift:**
- Generally still marital property
- Even if titled to one spouse
- Award based on factors
**Pet purchased before marriage:**
- Generally separate property
- Stays with original owner
- Unless transmuted (transferred title, joint care)
**Pet acquired during separation:**
- Often property of acquiring spouse
- Depends on state separation rules
**Pet death / loss:**
- Doesn't affect other property
- Insurance / vet bills allocated
- New pets after divorce: separate property
## Domestic violence + pets
**Pets used as leverage:**
- Threats to harm pet
- Withholding pet for control
- Many states' DV protective orders include pets
- Federal PAWS Act (2018) provides funding for DV-pet shelters
**Protective orders for pets** in many states.
## Practical tips for divorcing pet owners
**Build evidence of caretaking:**
- Photos of you with pet
- Vet records (your name on file)
- Insurance records
- Receipts (food, grooming)
- Time logs
- Witness statements
**Negotiate strategically:**
- Realistic about lifestyle
- Don't fight about emotional issues only
- Consider trade-offs
- Focus on pet's well-being
**Document arrangements:**
- Written agreements
- Specific schedules
- Decision-making provisions
- Cost allocation
## Tax + financial considerations
**Generally:**
- Pet purchase price = personal property value
- No tax deduction for pet care
- Service-animal medical deductions possible
- Pet-related expenses generally not deductible
- Pet trusts have specific tax rules
## What you should do
If you're divorcing in Vermont and pet custody matters: discuss informally first, document caretaking history, consider mediation, and be realistic about lifestyle changes. Vermont family attorneys handle pet custody as part of property division. Specific best-interest states may have more favorable procedures.
---
*This guide is general information about Vermont law as of mid-2026 and is not legal advice. Pet custody law is evolving. Talk to a licensed Vermont family-law attorney about your specific situation.*
This guide is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Laws change and outcomes depend on your specific situation — talk to a licensed attorney before acting on anything you read here.